This is a question I am asked all the time, especially by people who are considering studying abroad. Firstly, it is important to look at the differences between the two exams.
Cambridge offers English qualifications at different levels, from A1 right up to C2. The qualification commonly required by universities is the C1 exam, officially called C1 Advanced, although it is still widely known as CAE. The tasks in this exam are set at an advanced level and are designed primarily to assess C1-level English.
The exam has grown in popularity in Bulgaria in recent years, and at English Academy, more students take it than any other exam we offer. Although C1 Advanced is targeted at C1 level, candidates may receive the following results:
C1 Advanced assesses high-level English for study and work. Although some tasks may be set in academic or professional contexts, the exam does not test specialist academic knowledge.
IELTS, on the other hand, is available in two main versions: General Training and Academic. The General Training test is commonly taken by people who need proof of their English for work or migration, whereas the Academic test is the one normally requested by universities and other educational institutions.
Unlike C1 Advanced, IELTS is not designed for one particular CEFR level. All candidates take the same test and receive a band score from 1 to 9, reflecting their demonstrated level of English. The relationship between IELTS scores and CEFR levels is approximate rather than exact, but IELTS 5.5–6.5 generally corresponds to B2, while IELTS 7–8 corresponds to C1.
A major difference between the two qualifications concerns the validity of the results. A C1 Advanced certificate is valid indefinitely, whereas IELTS results are normally considered valid for two years. However, if you are planning to use C1 Advanced for university admission, some institutions may require you to have taken the exam within the previous two or three years.
For this reason, I advise students not to take either exam too early. The most popular time for students at English Academy to prepare for these exams is from September to December at the beginning of 11th grade, with the exam taken at the end of the course. This gives them time to focus on their other subjects during the remainder of 11th and 12th grade, knowing that they already have evidence of their English level if they decide to study abroad after finishing school.
Both exams are widely accepted by universities in Europe and elsewhere, but I always advise students to check the requirements of the universities they are considering. Individual institutions may accept both exams but set different minimum scores.
For example, a university might require an overall IELTS score of 6.5 or Grade C or higher in C1 Advanced. IELTS 6.5 is generally associated with a high B2 grade, whereas Grade C in C1 Advanced confirms C1-level performance. In this situation, I might recommend IELTS to a student who is approaching C1 but is not yet confident of achieving it in the C1 Advanced exam. However, universities may also require minimum IELTS scores in each of the four skills, so it is important to check the complete entry requirements.
To sum up, C1 Advanced may be the better choice if you are already a strong C1 candidate and would like a certificate that remains valid indefinitely. IELTS may be more suitable if you need the exam for migration, if a particular institution specifically requests it or if you are not yet confident of achieving C1 in the Cambridge exam.
Usually, I invite students to attend one of our free placement tests at the school. As part of the speaking assessment, I discuss their plans, current level and personal circumstances with them so that we can decide which exam is the better choice.
Mark McTaggart
English Academy Director
Have a question for Mark? Send it to us, and it may be answered in a future edition of "Ask Mark".